2023 Football Awards
Associated Press All-America
- Dalton Tjong - Jr. - 2nd Team
D3football.com All-America
- Dalton Tjong - Jr. - 4th Team
D3football.com All-Region 4
- Dalton Tjong - Jr. - 1st Team
- Josh Bever - Sr.-5 - 3rd Team
All-Ohio Athletic Conference
- Josh Bever - Sr.-5 - 1st Team
- Dalton Tjong - Jr. - 1st Team
- Noah Miller - Sr. - Honorable Mention
- Tyler Irigoyen - Sr.-5 - Honorable Mention
National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society
- Hunter King - Sr.
- Bryce Paul - Sr.
- Evan Tekancic - Sr.
College Sports Communicators Academic All-District
- Hunter King - Sr.
- Noah Miller - Sr.
- Connor Rowe - Sr.
- Jonmichael Elliott - Jr.
- Jordan Bassler - So.
- Louis Blasiole - So.
- Tyler Clum - So.
- Jacob Marjak - So.
Academic All-Ohio Athletic Conference
- Braeden Gedeon - Sr.
- Hunter King - Sr.
- Noah Miller - Sr.
- Bryce Paul - Sr.
- Connor Rowe - Sr.
- Peyton Wilson - Sr.
- Cade Crawford - Jr.
- Jonmichael Elliott - Jr.
- Lance Good - Jr.
- Matt Howard - Jr.
- Tyler Clum - So.
- Jordan Bassler - So.
- Louis Blasiole - So.
- Cody Dykes - So.
- Alex Frimel - So.
- Jacob Marjak - So.
- Trevor Prudhoe - So.
- Karl Slader - So.
- Austin Stauffer - So.
OAC Player of the Week
- Brennon Norris - Jr. - Offensive - Nov. 12
- Dalton Tjong - Jr. - Defensive - Nov. 12
- Ed Manning - Sr. - Special Teams - Nov. 6
- Brennon Norris - Jr. - Offensive - Sept. 11
- Jonmichael Elliott - Jr. - Special Teams - Sept. 11
- Dalton Tjong - Jr. - Defensive - Sept. 5
Polar Bear of the Month
- Dalton Tjong - Jr. - November