2021 Men's Soccer Awards
Ohio Collegiate Soccer Association All-Ohio Team
- Levi King - Sr. - MF - 1st Team
- John Lombardo - Sr. - GK - 2nd Team
- Caiman Moore - Sr. - D - 2nd Team
- Seth Gundlach - Sr. - F - 3rd Team
Ohio Collegiate Soccer Association Academic All-Ohio Team
- Levi King - Sr. - MF - 1st Team
- John Lombardo - Sr. - GK - 1st Team
- Caiman Moore - Sr. - D - 2nd Team
- Seth Gundlach - Sr. - F - 2nd Team
- Matt Studenic - Sr. - M - 2nd Team
United Soccer Coaches All-Region 7 Team
- Levi King - Sr. - MF - 2nd Team
- John Lombardo - Sr. - GK - 3rd Team
- Caiman Moore - Sr. - D - 3rd Team
OAC Goalkeeper of the Year
- John Lombardo - Sr. - GK
OAC Midfielder of the Year
- Levi King - Sr. - MF
All-Ohio Athletic Conference
- Levi King - Sr. - MF - 1st Team
- John Lombardo - Sr. - GK - 1st Team
- Seth Gundlach - Sr. - F - 2nd Team
- Bryan Kern - Sr. - F - 2nd Team
- Caiman Moore - Sr. - D - 2nd Team
- Cameron Picard - Sr. - D - 3rd Team
- Matt Studenic - Sr. - M - 3rd Team
Academic All-Ohio Athletic Conference
- Joe Bement - Sr. - M
- Seth Gundlach - Sr. - F
- Caiman Moore - Sr. - B
- Cameron Picard - Sr. - B
- Matt Studenic - Sr. - M
- Jacob Westerkamp - Sr. - B
- Jeff Firestone - Jr. - M
- Ryan Augustine - So. - F
- Cade Winchester - So. - M
United Soccer Coaches College Team Academic Award
- Ohio Northern - 3.23 GPA
All-OAC Tournament
- John Lombardo - Sr. - GK
- Seth Gundlach - Sr. - F
OAC Player of the Week
- John Lombardo - Sr. - Defensive - Nov. 1