2009 Football Awards
D3Football.com All-America
- Andrew Benchic - Sr - OL - Second Team
- Brent Donley - Jr - RB - Third Team
D3Football.com All-North Region
- Andrew Benchic - Sr - OL - First Team
- Brent Donley - Jr - RB - First Team
- Josh Horn - Sr - DE - Third Team
- Jake Heaphy - Sr - P/K - Third Team
Academic All-Ohio Athletic Conference
- Rick Ingold - Sr - OL - First Team
- Kyle Simmons - Jr - QB - First Team
All-Ohio Athletic Conference
- Jake Heaphy - Sr - P/K - First Team
- Andrew Benchic- Sr - OL - First Team
- Josh Horn - Sr - DE - First Team
- Brent Donley - Jr - RB - First Team
- Kyle Simmons - Jr - QB - First Team (Bob Packard Award as Offensive Back of the Year)
- J.J. Mihoci - Jr - KR - First Team
- Gabe Washington - Sr - LB - Second Team
- Rick Ingold - Sr - OL - Honorable Mention
- Justin Linzy - Sr - WR - Honorable Mention
ESPN The Magazine Academic All-District IV
- Rick Ingold - Sr - OL - First Team
- Kyle Simmons - Jr - QB - 2nd Team
- Eric Wenzler - Jr - DB - 2nd Team
- Evan Elliott - Jr - HB - 2nd Team
D3Football.com Team of the Week
- Rick Ingold, Andrew Benchic, Pat Smith, Justin Southwick, Dave Beale - OL - Oct. 27
- Jake Heaphy - Sr - K - Oct. 20
Ohio Athletic Conference Players of the Week
- Chad Coward - So - S - Special Teams, Nov. 16
- Jake Heaphy - Sr - P/K - Special Teams, Nov.9
- Jeremy Wyant - Sr - DT - Defensive - Nov. 2
- Jake Heaphy - Sr - P/K - Special Teams - Nov. 2
- Brent Donley - Jr - RB - Offensive - Oct. 26
- Jake Heaphy - Sr - P/K - Special Teams - Oct. 26
- Jake Heaphy - Sr - P/K - Special Teams - Oct. 19
- Kyle Simmons - Jr - QB - Offensive - Oct. 19
- Kyle Simmons - Jr - QB - Offensive - Oct. 12
Josh Horn - Jr - DE - Defensive - Oct. 5